Women’s Leadership in the Church
according to Christian Tradition

by John Wijngaards

Lesson 2
Characteristics of authentic Tradition


Lesson two
Characteristics of authentic Tradition


  • * read the narration column first
  • * then do the exercises

Reading

Textbook, The Ordination of Women, etc., Chapter 2, ‘Papal teaching on slavery’, pp. 8-16.

Exercise 1

  • In a discussion with the Pharisees of his time, Jesus said: “You make God’s word null and void for the sake of your tradition which you have handed down.” Read: Mark 7,1-13. Could this apply to the Church too?

How to distinguish between true Christian ‘Tradition’ and human ‘tradition’ [= custom, practice, etc.]?

In the context of the Church, ‘Tradition’ is the handing over from generation to generation of the Revelation contained in the Christ event. Scripture and Tradition go hand in hand. Tradition develops and grows by a deeper understanding of what the revealed message contains. And by no means everything done in the past was part of the authentic Christian Tradition.

Valid Catholic Tradition possesses the following four characteristics:

  • 1. Valid Tradition is scriptural.
    This means that it must be based on a correct understanding of the inspired meaning of scriptural texts. In the history of the Church, such a correct understanding often went hand in hand with a new awareness of important issues. The new, correct interpretation of Scripture comes about through the undying activity of the Holy Spirit in the Church.
    Read: Valid Tradition is scriptural.

  • 2. Valid Tradition is informed.
    For it to be informed, the carriers of the Tradition must have correctly understood the question and the issues that are at stake. As Pope Pius XII stated in Divino Afflante Spiritu (1943): “There are many matters, especially historical, which were insufficiently or hardly at all developed by the commentators of past centuries, because they lacked nearly all information needful for elucidating them”.
    Read: Valid Tradition is informed.

   

Exercise 2

  • Are these discussions about the interpretation of Tradition new to you? Can you reformulate the principles in your own words?
  • Can you give other examples from the history of Christianity that require the application of these principles?

  • 3. Valid Tradition can be ‘latent’ [hidden] for many centuries.
    The history of the Church demonstrates that we should study the past carefully. Underneath the practice and hidden under explicit texts, there may lie a contrary, but valid latent Tradition, a Tradition that is faithful to the teaching of the Gospel and transmitted through the centuries without always being explicitly recognised as such.
    Read: Valid Tradition can be latent.

  • 4. Valid Tradition shows development through a dynamic growth.
    True Tradition is not static. It grows; not in the sense that it differs substantially from the inspiration received from Jesus Christ and the Apostles, but in the sense that many of its latent implications are gradually realised with the help of the Holy Spirit.
    Read: Valid Tradition is dynamic.
   
 

What is at stake

Authentic Tradition

Early Church

Women Deacons

The Fathers

Middle Ages

Church Law

Post-
medieval

Spurious tradition

Latent tradition